We received the Leaf as a gift and loved it from the start. However, since there were two, we knew we still needed another swing. On a trip to the store to return some baby items, I once again saw the mamaRoo. After collecting our return money and looking at the gift cards we had in hand, I decided why not give the mamaRoo a chance. I mean, most people consider me an early adopter of technology, why not live up to my reputation. What did I have to lose? If it worked, then great. If it didn't work, then back to the store it would go. To this day, I am glad I took that chance.
The Nuna Leaf
What I consider to be one of the minimally looking swings on the market is the Nuna Leaf. The Leaf moves just as it sounds, like a leaf falling from a tree. It swings on an single axis point, from side to side with just the slightest push. It can also be locked in a stationary position by pressing on a lever near its base. There are no batteries to change, no cords to trip on, it's just a simple elegant swing that can be put anywhere in the house. One of the most important features was that it could be used from birth to 130 lbs. A full review of the specs can be found at Nuna's website. The toy bar was purchased separately. For us, it is great to put the baby in the Leaf and gently give it a push and the baby is off and floating away. Whenever it stops, which usually takes a few minutes, we can give it a slight tap/nudge with our foot and the Leaf is off again. In my opinion, it is the Hipster of the swings.
mamaRoo to the Rescue
Now to the mamaRoo. I love it. Yes, I am a tech guy, but I am also the dad of twin boys. While the Nuna Leaf is elegant and minimal, the mamaRoo is just the opposite. It is big, loud and definitely doesn't blend in well with the surroundings. However, it has been a life saver on a number of occasions.
The mamaRoo is the technology king of swings. It has 5 unique motions - car ride, kangaroo, tree swing, rock a bye and the ocean. These motions are created by moving from side to side and up and down. The mamaRoo also has a number of built in nature sounds and can be hooked up to an mp3 player via a headphone jack located in the base. The volume can be adjusted and the speaker is loud enough to fill an entire room. Additionally, the seat can also be set to recline, although to be honest, we just recently moved it from the cradle to the sitting up position. There is also an newborn insert that can be purchased. I would recommend this for any small babies. We used our insert until they were almost 14lbs. The weight limit of the mamaRoo is 25 lbs. Additional pictures and specs can be found on the 4mom website.
Now, why would you need the mamaRoo and how did it come to my rescue? One of the biggest problems for parents with twins is that each of you only have two hands. This is especially problematic when only one parent is at home with the twins. When it rains, it pours. For example, the twins are tired. You think to yourself, now is a good time to put them in their crib for a quick nap. You start to put them down and suddenly it's like their mattress is made of hot lava or is a bed of nails. Both are suddenly screaming louder and louder. This is a time for the mamaRoo. I place one in the mamaRoo, set it on car ride, and put it on high. He almost immediately calms down and allows me the chance to take the other in my arms and rock him to sleep. After that, I can take him out of the mamaRoo and rock him to sleep. However, most of the time, he is out like a light too. At that point, it's just ramping down the speed of the mamaRoo slowly and then putting him to sleep in his crib. I can't recommend the mamaRoo enough. It has been a life and sleep saver.
It is unfair to compare these swings to each other. In my opinion, both are exceptional at what they do. The mamaRoo is great for being able to put a baby in it, press a button and it's off to adventure land. It has every option you could imagine except for a remote. Which to be honest, would have come in handy, but probably would not be the safest idea. However, it also has a limited life span and is pricey. The Leaf is minimal and sleek and will be used for years to come, but requires some attention and is also priced higher than other swings. I highly recommend both for the reasons above.